History of Paraguay contra its Falsifiers: Chapter XII

History of Paraguay contra its Falsifiers: Chapter XII

The Battle Rages On…

On 17 June 1811, the Junta Superior Gubernativa a.k.a. Junta de Asunción was established. Don Bernardo de Velasco, the last Spaniard Governor of Paraguay and Misiones was sacked and a new government of Creoles and Mestizos was formed. In a certain way, this was still a legitimate rule that tried to follow the forms. Velasco ceded, without any violence (if we ignore his imprisonment on 9 June 1811) all the atributes of power to the new Junta and indeed, he was part of the Paraguayan First Junta, the «Triumvirate», contrary to what happened in Buenos Aires from where Don Baltasar Hidalgo de los Cisneros was simply expelled during the «May Revolution». In Paraguay, the «hermeneutics of reform in continuity» was taking place. In Buenos Aires, there was nothing but the «hermeneutics of rupture and revolution».

The main reason alluded by the Paraguayan Junta about the sacking of Governor Velasco was explained in a lengthy letter adressed to Don Carlos Martínez the Marquis of Irujo y Tacón (1765-1824), who was serving as the Spaniard Ambassador in Río de Janeiro. The «Próceres» claimed they removed Don Bernardo from his position as Governor of the First Junta (Triumvirate) because of his plan (alongside Governor Vigodet in Montevideo) of allowing the Portuguese Army to enter in the Spaniard Territories of the River Plate in order to impulse what we know today as the Carlotista Movement. With this attitude, he went completely against the instructions he recieved from the Marquis of Irujo himself. Hence, the Paraguayan Junta was simply following the orders given by the Marquis and arrested Velasco, who had no justification whatsoever, not even if that Carlotista Movement was to be done for «subjugating the revolutionaries of Buenos Aires». Then the «Próceres» rambled on with versions about the poor situation of the country under Velasco’s rule, his cowardice facing the Porteño Revolutionary Enemy and his utter refusal of entering in friendly terms with Belgrano and Buenos Aires (these lines were inspired by the «Porteñistas» in the Junta of Asunción). However, thanks to the influence of Dr. Francia (who just returned to the Junta after his first self-retirement), the Paraguayans declared once again their total allegiance to the Spaniard Crown and King Ferdinand VII while asking to the Marquis of Irujo for advise and counsel. [1]

From the «Próceres» of Buenos Aires, not a single document of a similar note, showing total obedience and allegiance to Spain in a direct and clear action, and with such a respectful tone towards a Spaniard Minster Envoy, was ever found. Quite contrary, the anglophile slave of liberalism and Secretary of the Junta Porteña, Don Mariano Moreno, in 1810 wrote to the same Marquis de Irujo y Tacón with bitter, insulting and scathing terms with an attack to the «Junta of Cadiz» while defending the «Junta of Buenos Aires» (coherence a-la-porteña some would say):

«Our peoples in America are enjoying the same privileges as the ones in Spain, our Junta couldn’t reprobate herself while recognizing their privilege, nor accept the denigrating and retrograde step back to the humilliating colonial state from which we were liberated in the face of the whole world…». [2]

An enormous difference between treasonous Buenos Aires and loyalist Paraguay!

That’s why everyone talks about the «Mask of Ferdinand VII» in Buenos Aires. The Porteños never wanted to remain loyal to Don Fernando VII. It was a charade, an absolute farce used to enforce the despotic Buenosairean Centralism and Unitarianism over the rest of the Provinces that were very loyal to the Spaniard Crown. When Don Cornelio de Saavedra, First President of the Junta of Buenos Aires, claimed to Don Baltasar Hidalgo de los Cisneros that the said Junta «… doesn’t want to follow the destiny of Spain nor doesn’t want to be ruled by France but to rule itself on its own, preserving their own rights and guarding themselves because the authority (of the Spanish Crown) no longer exists, so your own authority no longer exists…», he is simply expressing, with elegant words and total transparency, the undeniable reality: Porteños were far away from trying to remain loyal to the King of Spain. [3]

Another well known claim about a «cause for independence», as pushed forward by Porteño liberals and their Paraguayan servants, was the alleged imposibility of the Creoles and Mestizos of becoming part of the higher branches of government in the Provinces. But this, even if something of the kind started to take place under the Bourbon’s, was simply a lie that can be proven with very easy examples from the Paraguayan «Próceres» themselves: General Fulgencio Yegros was a high officer under Don Bernardo de Velasco and he even became Lieutenant Governor of Misiones; Captain Pedro Juan Caballero, being a very young man in 1811, was already a respected officer; José Gaspar de Francia phD. was a Judge of First Instance (Alcalde de Primer Voto) and Fiscal Procurator of the Exchequer (Procuador de la Real Hacienda) before becoming Deputy of the Cabildo; young 2nd Lieutenant (Alférez) Vicente Ignacio Iturbe was the Ensign of the City; Captain Mauricio José Troche was the first officer of the Barracks of La Rivera and Commander of the Curuguaty Platoon; Mariano Antonio Molas was a attorney and judiciary agent; Dr. Fernando de la Mora served as a public lawyer and Regidor (Council Member) of the City of Asunción; Father Francisco Javier de Bogarín was a respected priest and Antonio Tomás Yegros, brother of Fulgencio, also held a high military position before the Paraguayan Independence. So only by mentioning the past of the «Próceres» in Asunción, the propaganda impulsed by Buenos Aires about the so called «desprecio a los criollos y mestizos» (despise towards créoles and mestizos) is shown as what it is: just another blatant porteñista lie. [4]

Therefore, everything gets reduced to a whimsical and lunatic desire: the attempt of the liberal Porteños, mystified by the anglo masonic sects, of imposing their arbitrary will over all the provinces, no more and no less. But following the same logic exposed by Cornelio de Saavedra about the «extinction» of the Spaniard Royal Authority by the Napoleonic Invasion, if we consider that reasoning as a fact, the obvious question comes along: under what authority Buenos Aires could have claimed for itself the title of «Capital» and «Head» of the Provinces of the River Plate? An English idiom explains with striking equivalence the contradictory and nonsensical position of the Porteños: «you can’t have the cake and eat it too». After seeing this, it doesn’t matter how much authors like Ezcurra Medrano talk about the «dismemberment» and the «separatism» of Paraguay in relation to Buenos Aires. The only real fact is that the Porteños (and their liberal-doctrinnaire vassals) were the real separatists and the real traitors to Spain and the Catholic Majesties. [5]

The First Junta of Buenos Aires (25 May - 18 December 1810), a symbol of revolutionary liberalism. Under false pretenses (like "the Mask of Ferdinand VII"), the "Próceres" Porteños and their servants tried to impose their whimsical, arbitrary and lunatic will upon the rest of the Provinces of the River Plate. Traditionalist Paraguay was the fiercest opponent to Buenos Aires. [Image: Chajarí Digital].
The First Junta of Buenos Aires (25 May – 18 December 1810), a symbol of revolutionary liberalism. Under false pretenses (like «the Mask of Ferdinand VII»), the «Próceres» Porteños and their servants tried to impose their whimsical, arbitrary and lunatic will upon the rest of the Provinces of the River Plate. Traditionalist Paraguay was the fiercest opponent to Buenos Aires. [Image: Chajarí Digital].

But things weren’t looking very good in Paraguay either. The new Junta was trying to follow the baneful steps of Buenos Aires. On 19 June 1811, Don Mariano Antonio Molas, a very influential «Prócer» and Paraguayan porteñista, proposed:

«Not only Paraguay has to keep friendly relationships with Buenos Aires, but he should also unite with her to form a new society based on the principles of justice, equity and equality… In this sense, Dr. Francia should be appointed as deputy in order to represent our Province in the General Congress announced Buenos Aires… And we should suspend all relationships with Spain until the supreme decision of the Congress of Buenos Aires is taken». [6]

This was accepted by the whole Junta, with the exception of Dr. Francia, whom refused to be sent to Buenos Aires and to be reduced into an instrument of Buenos Aires. The plan of the Porteñistas was, in fact, to remove Don José Gaspar from Asunción since his influence amongst the populace was unmatchable and he was also seen with great suspicion by the military members of the Paraguayan Junta. They thought that Dr. Francia was some kind of a crypto-royalist, and probably, they were right about that but things would evolve differently from that moment onwards.

In order to prevent any attempt of absorption by the Porteños, Dr. Francia played another gamble. With the approval of his peers, he dictated a letter (that was written down by Don Fernando de la Mora), adressed to the Junta of Buenos Aires. This document was visionary and in the same time, it was a proposal for a restoration of the Spanish Old Ways in the River Plate. In this historical piece, Francia proclaimed the total Independence and Autonomy of Paraguay towards Buenos Aires, the loyalty of Paraguay to the cause of the Spaniard Monarchy and its pledge to defend the rights of King Don Fernando VII and the necessity to retain the union of the provinces of the River Plate under a system of confederation. His exact words about the «Confederation», as transcribed by de La Mora, were: «The Confederation of this Province with the rest of the Provinces of Our America and most importantly, with the ones that belonged to the former Viceroyalty (of the River Plate), should be of the most immediate and affordable interestand therefore, the most natural one, since we are peoples not just of the same origin but also joined together by common and particular interests that are destined by nature itself to be joined and living together for our conservation». [7]

For the Spaniard author, Don José Manuel Rodríguez Pardo, this move by Dr. Francia made him the «Father of American Integrationism» and also «Precursor of the Hispanidad (Spanishness)». On the other hand, Bartolomé Mitre affirms that this document inspired by the famous «Supremo of Paraguay» became the cornerstone and the foundational basis of the idea of a «Federation» in the history of Independent Argentina. [8]

Francia’s idea was nothing more but to restore the traditional system of government created by the legendary Catholic Kings Don Fernando (Ferdinand of Aragon) and Doña Isabel (Isabella of Castile). When these two great monarchs united by marriage, they joined their kingdoms via personal union and the natural result was the birth of a «Confederate System» that was at the heart of the Spaniard’s future glory and success. After this, the «Kingdom of Spain» would evolve and transform itself into the first global superpower in modern history with an «Empire in which the Sun Never Sets». [9]

The Bourbons with their liberal and enlightened reforms brought several changes to this Confederate System and the Porteños were the main defenders of the «Centralist», «Absolutist» and «Unitarian» Government, while the Paraguayans inspired by Dr. Francia were the champions of the traditional Trastámara-Habsburg ideal of a «Confederation» under a common monarch. These are legitimate glories of Paraguay, land of loyalty and tradition. These are the things that the «Historical School of Porteñismo» desperately wanted to keep hidden. Asunción, the Mother City of the River Plate, could never have been a traitor to her own mother, the Catholic Crown of Spain. On the contrary, Buenos Aires, under inspiration of the enlightened despotism and sectarian liberalism, was the ones pushing for the dismemberment of the whole region, with no authority whatsoever on its favour to sustain any of its claims.

But the Buenosaireans had a lot of strings to pull in the Junta of Asunción. The military element, led by Don Fulgencio Yegros, were promoters of the Porteñista Agenda. They conjured up in the Cabildo in order to remove Dr. Francia from his influential position. Notorious Don José Gaspar, in preventive maneuvers, resigned two times and retired himself to his countryhouse at Ibiray just before the «Porteñistas» of the Junta could expel him or even worse, imprison him. His first resignation was on 30 July 1811. [10]

In the absence of Francia, the Junta tried once more to get closer to Buenos Aires. They sent notes and communications expressing their desires of uniting with the Porteño’s City in order to form a single nation. This language had nothing to do with the «Confederate System» proposed by Francia, rather, it was an attempt to follow the «Unitarian» and «Centralist» line of the liberal sectarians of Buenos Aires. The Cabildo of Asunción (under the presidence of Don Juan Valeriano de Zeballos), after knowing about the maneuvers of the Junta Superior Gubernativa, desperately summoned back Dr. Francia, who returned to Asunción from his first retirement on 6 September 1811.

Paraguay loathed the idea of being annexed by Buenos Aires and this old battle was still raging on…

REFERENCES.

[1] The Honourable Junta Gubernativa del Paraguay (Fulgencio Yegros, José Gaspar de Francia, Pedro Juan Caballero, Fernando de la Mora) to the Most Excellent Marqués Carlos Martínez de Irujo y Tacón, Envoy Minister of Spain in Río de Janeiro. Asunción, 26 September 1811. Available at: Doroteo Bareiro Collection (Colección Doroteo Bareiro), volume I, restored by Richard Alan White. Asunción, Paraguay.

[2] «Reflexiones sobre una Proclama Publicada en el Brasil», available in Moreno, Mariano (1949): «Escritos – Con Prólogo y Edición Crítica de Ricardo Levene», volume I, pages 121-139. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Colección Clásicos Argentinos, Ediciones Estrada, in two volumes.

[3] Saavedra, Cornelio (1960): «Memoria autógrafa», in Biblioteca de Mayo. Colección de obras y documentos para la historia argentina. Autobiografías II: page 1052. Buenos Aires, Argentina.

[4] «Próceres de la Independencia», short biographies of the main actors in the Paraguayan Indenpendence. Available at: «Casa de la Independencia 1811-2011». Retrieved: 25 May 2021. Link: https://www.casadelaindependencia.org.py/proceres.html

[5] Ezcurra Medrano, Alberto (1941): «La Independencia del Paraguay…»., op. cit. page 5.

[6] Ezcurra Medrano (1941): «La Independencia del Paraguay…», op. cit. pages 10-11.

[7] Rodríguez Pardo (2011): «La Independencia del Paraguay no fue Proclamada en Mayo de 1811…», op.cit. pages 73-74.

[8] Mitre, Bartolomé (1887): «Historia de Belgrano y la Independencia Argentina…», op. cit. vol. II, pages 27-28. – It should be noticed that the exact word used by Francia and De la Mora was «Confederation». So here, either Mitre is falsifying history once again or he just used the words «Federation» and «Confederation» as synonyms, something that could show either an extreme literary liberty, utter ignorance of the difference, or both.

[9] Pendrill, Colin (2002): «Spain 1474-1700: The Triumphs and Tribulations of Empire», pages 209-210. London, Britain: Heinemann.

[10] Garay, Blas (2009): «La Revolución de la Independencia del Paraguay, La Junta Superior Gubernativa, El Primer Consulado», pages 105 and 159. Asunción, Paraguay: Servilibro.

Emilio Urdapilleta

171 comentarios en «History of Paraguay contra its Falsifiers: Chapter XII»

  1. Whhats up very nice blog!! Guy .. Excellent .. Wonderful
    .. I will bookmark your website and take the feeds also?
    I’m happy to seek out numerous useful info right here
    inn the publish, we’d like work out mode strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing.
    . . . . .

  2. I read this piece of writing fully regarding the comparison of hottest and previous technologies, it’s awesome article.

  3. What a material of un-ambiguity and preserveness of precious
    know-how on the topic of unpredicted emotions.

  4. My partner and I stumbled over here different page and thought
    I may as well check things out. I like what I see so now i’m following you.
    Look forward to exploring your web page repeatedly.

  5. In order to run your overall dwelling or Business on Surfshark’s VPN, you
    don’t need to be concerned about the number of products you may have on or connected.
    It also provides antimalware, advertisement-blocking and tracker-blocking as part of
    its software program.

    Best VoIP for little business people — whether or not you’re WFH or
    not Reliability is essential and a VoIP can help you get there.

    10 Simultaneous Connections With FastestVPN multi-unit connections, you might have numerous
    gadgets related suddenly. Our easy to use app helps you to link ten equipment with out owning you to subscribe for one more account.
    Hook up any of one’s equipment and revel in substantial-high quality streaming with blazing pace.

    Think about it this way: If your car pulls out within your
    driveway, another person can observe you
    and find out where you are going, just how long
    you will be at your destination, and when you are coming back.

    They may even manage to peek inside your car or truck and find out more
    about you. Using a VPN, it’s as in the event you push from
    your property into an underground tunnel, right into a closed parking garage, change to another motor vehicle, and
    push out. No one who was at first following you understands where you
    went.

    Boasting exceptional speeds and responsible connections, IPVanish is a viable selection for Firestick VPN.

    Remember that it may well struggle with unblocking
    some common streaming platforms, which includes BBC iPlayer. 

    ProtonVPN ProtonVPN provides the best cost-free subscription tiers we have seen,
    and its compensated tiers provide access to several privateness
    tools at an affordable price.

    Because we’re living in a related environment, protection and privacy are crucial to guarantee our personalized protection from nefarious hacks.
    From online banking to communicating with co-workers on a regular basis, we’re now routinely transferring facts on our desktops and smartphones.

    Finally, NoBorders Method «enables [you] to correctly use Surfshark in restrictive regions.» Just watch out.
    Performing any of these a few points may be illegal inside your region and will
    bring about serious penalties. In the course of our tests,
    we didn’t see only one IP address or DNS leak, and had no trouble accessing Netflix.

    It’s not a awful choice for intermittent use, but
    if you’re a each day consumer or heavy traveler, you might want to go
    another route. 

    It’s got a stable assortment of servers and around the world locations.
    For people of you who require a focused IP, you can obtain 1 from the company,
    but You will need to Call aid to obtain support environment it up.

    Used by Google DoubleClick and shops details about how the person makes
    use of the website and every other advertisement before going to
    the website. This is often utilized to current customers with
    advertisements which are suitable to them in accordance with
    the user profile.

    Additionally they would not be able to see personal data like passwords, usernames
    and lender or purchasing particulars and the like. Anyone who would like to safeguard their privacy and safety online need to
    use a VPN.

    IPVanish is amongst the more popular applications for Kodi and Firestick end
    users. You could download the app straight from the Amazon app keep which makes it quick to put in and setup.
    The app alone is easy to use and will work along with your Firestick distant. 

    Ad cookies are applied to provide readers with relevant ads and promoting campaigns.

    These cookies track guests across Web sites and obtain data to deliver
    tailored adverts.

  6. Awesome blog! Do you have any suggestions for aspiring writers?
    I’m hoping to start my own blog soon but I’m a little lost on everything.
    Would you advise starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so
    many options out there that I’m completely overwhelmed
    .. Any ideas? Thanks!

  7. Hi there, its nice paragraph regarding media print, we all
    be familiar with media is a impressive source of facts.

  8. Excellent weblog right here! Also your web site so much up very fast!
    What host are you using? Can I get your associate link in your host?
    I desire my web site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  9. Для вас шестнадцать свежих сериалов для фанатов фэнтези.
    Чики смотреть онлайн новый сезон, новые серии.
    Выбирайте по рейтингу кинопоиска, Сериалы жанра “Боевик”.
    Аналогично все мы готов предоставить меню каналов Киномикс, HD НТВ, 4K 1+1, прямой эфир Матч ТВ, трансляция Eurosport 1.

  10. Приготовили для Вас пятнадцать с высоким рейтингом сериалов для фанатов
    мистики. Тайсон Фьюри – Деонтей Уайлдер прямая трансляция. серия 5,10..17, 1-18..100 все серии,
    смотреть онлайн. Смотрите по намеченой дате
    выхода, Сериалы жанра “Детектив”.
    Ещё мы вам выдает перечень различных каналов CNN,
    HD Paramount Comedy Россия, 4K ТВ Центр, прямой
    эфир 2х2, трансляция Первый канал.

  11. С любовью для вас девятнадцать новых сериалов для поклонников романтических
    комедий. Бумажный дом 5 сезон 7 серия смотреть онлайн все серии подряд, смотреть онлайн.
    Смотрите по мировому рейтингу,
    Сериалы жанра “Фантастика”.
    Да и здесь мы дает меню различных каналов Канал Disney, HD
    Eurosport 1, 4K Мега, прямой эфир Первый канал, трансляция
    ТВ Центр.

  12. Опять для вас пятнадцать рейтинговых сериалов
    для ценителей хорора. Когда выйдет полицейский с Рублевки 7 сезон дата выхода, новых серий.

    Смотрите по намеченой дате выхода, Сериалы жанра “История”.
    Ещё мы вам готова предоставить
    номенклатуру различных каналов Пятый канал, HD
    Мир, 4K К1, прямой эфир Суббота, трансляция Звезда.

Deja una respuesta

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada.